Open Care Data

Independent record · no sponsored results

Best Nursing Homes in Erie County, New York

Compare safety records, ratings, staffing and citations side by side, then get alerted when they change.

Terms of Use & Disclaimer

Highest-rated nursing homes in Erie County CMS five-star, 34 on record

1. Fox Run At Orchard Park
Orchard Park · health inspections 5/5 · staffing 5/5
5 ★
2. St Catherine Laboure Health Care Center
Buffalo · health inspections 5/5 · staffing 5/5
5 ★
3. Mercy Hospital Skilled Nursing Facility
Lackawanna · health inspections 4/5 · staffing 5/5
5 ★
4. Beechwood Homes
Getzville · health inspections 5/5 · staffing 4/5
5 ★
5. Mcauley Residence
Kenmore · health inspections 5/5 · staffing 4/5
5 ★

Ranked by the CMS overall star rating (ties broken by staffing, then health inspections), excluding facilities with a federal abuse flag or on the Special Focus watch list. 33 of the 34 nursing homes in Erie County are Medicaid-certified; certification does not guarantee an open Medicaid bed, so confirm with the facility. How we rank.

Recent changes in Erie County October 2026 federal update

Elderwood At Hamburg
Hamburg, NY
Abuse indicator added
Elderwood At Hamburg
Hamburg, NY
3 → 1 ★
Father Baker Manor
Orchard Park, NY
5 → 3 ★
Canterbury Woods
Williamsville, NY
3 → 4 ★
Elderwood At Amherst
Amherst, NY
2 → 3 ★
Garden Gate Health Care Facility
Cheektowaga, NY
2 → 3 ★

Compared with the September 2026 federal release. See all NY rating changes →

Name