Open Care Data
Independent Review & Safety Record · CCN 43A038 Monitoring available

SCOTCHMAN LIVING CENTER

An independent review of Scotchman Living Center's safety record, its Medicare rating, health-inspection citations, staffing, fines and complaints, drawn from public federal data (not user star-ratings).

503 WEST PINE · PHILIP, SD 57567 · 42 beds · Medicaid certified
Phone: 6058592583
B
Open Care Data Safety Grade

This facility rates above average, with a mostly solid record.

Starts from the Medicare rating, then weighs 4 serious citation(s). How we grade · See how it compares
Open Care Data's independent assessment of public federal data, not an official CMS rating. Data can lag or change. Operate this facility? Report a correction.

Recent News October 2026 federal update

Overall rating improved from 3 to 4 stars

In the October 2026 federal update, this facility's Medicare overall rating improved from 3 of 5 stars to 4. The overall rating combines health inspections, staffing, and quality measures into a single Medicare five-star score. A higher rating reflects a change in the facility's measured performance in that area versus the prior release.

Staffing rating improved from 4 to 5 stars

In the October 2026 federal update, this facility's Medicare staffing rating improved from 4 of 5 stars to 5. The staffing rating reflects nurse hours per resident per day and staff turnover. A higher rating reflects a change in the facility's measured performance in that area versus the prior release.

Registered-nurse turnover changed from 60% to 40%

In the October 2026 federal update, this facility's reported registered-nurse turnover changed from 60% to 40%. Higher turnover can make continuity of care harder to maintain.

These changes are drawn from the U.S. federal (CMS) nursing home data. The facts are CMS's; the explanations are Open Care Data's. Federal data updates periodically and can lag current conditions. Operate this facility? Add context or report a correction.

Medicare Five-Star Rating · as of the latest federal update

Overall
★★★★★
4 / 5
Staffing
★★★★★
5 / 5
Health Inspection
★★★★★
4 / 5
Quality Measures
★★★★★
1 / 5

Top concerns What stands out in the record

  • 4 citation(s) reached the 'actual harm' severity level or higher.

How it compares vs. 98 SD nursing homes

Overall Medicare rating
4of 5 stars
Better than 62% of SD homes
Staffing rating
5of 5 stars
Better than 74% of SD homes
Health-inspection rating
4of 5 stars
Better than 62% of SD homes
Total nurse hours / resident / day
5.01991hrs
Better than 91% of SD homes
RN hours / resident / day
0.94802hrs
Better than 79% of SD homes
RN turnover
40%
Better than 40% of SD homes

Percentiles rank this facility against every other Medicare-rated nursing home in South Dakota, using the latest federal data.

Free monitoring

Get an alert if this facility's record changes

We'll email you if its Medicare rating drops, or a new citation, fine, or complaint is filed. Free, unsubscribe anytime.

Safety & Enforcement Federal inspection record

Safety indicators

Abuse indicator None on record
Substantiated complaints 0

Financial penalties

3
Fines
$47,655
Total fines
0
Payment denials
3
Total penalties

Staffing Hours per resident / day

0.94802
RN hours per resident / day
Benchmark ≥ 0.75
5.01991
Total nursing hours / day
Benchmark ≈ 4.1
4.51049
Weekend nursing hours / day
Look for parity with weekdays

Higher staffing, especially RN time, correlates with better outcomes and higher Medicare star ratings.

Recent Deficiency Citations Last 36 months · federal inspections

Loading citation record…

Quality Measures Medicare quality data · lower is better

Loading quality measures…

Highly-rated facilities nearby Same area · by rating