Open Care Data
Independent Review & Safety Record · CCN 525657 Monitoring available

Montello Care Center

An independent review of Montello Care Center's safety record, its Medicare rating, health-inspection citations, staffing, fines and complaints, drawn from public federal data (not user star-ratings).

251 Forest Lane · Montello, WI 53949 · 50 beds
Phone: 6082972153
F
Open Care Data Safety Grade

This facility raises serious safety concerns and ranks well below its peers.

Starts from the Medicare rating, then weighs below-average staffing; high RN turnover (75%); $142,634 in federal fines. How we grade · See how it compares
Open Care Data's independent assessment of public federal data, not an official CMS rating. Data can lag or change. Operate this facility? Report a correction.

Recent News August 2026 federal update

Staffing rating declined from 3 to 1 stars

In the August 2026 federal update, this facility's Medicare staffing rating declined from 3 of 5 stars to 1. The staffing rating reflects nurse hours per resident per day and staff turnover. A lower rating reflects a change in the facility's measured performance in that area versus the prior release.

Total federal fines changed to $142,634

In the August 2026 federal update, the total dollar amount of federal fines on this facility's record changed from $163,039 to $142,634. Fines are civil monetary penalties CMS levies when serious problems are identified and not corrected.

These changes are drawn from the U.S. federal (CMS) nursing home data. The facts are CMS's; the explanations are Open Care Data's. Federal data updates periodically and can lag current conditions. Operate this facility? Add context or report a correction.

Medicare Five-Star Rating · as of the latest federal update

Overall
1 / 5
Staffing
1 / 5
Health Inspection
1 / 5
Quality Measures
★★
2 / 5

Top concerns What stands out in the record

  • Below-average overall Medicare rating (1 of 5 stars).
  • $142,634 in federal fines across 2 penalties.
  • Staffing rating is in the bottom tier, often the strongest predictor of care quality.
  • High registered-nurse turnover (75%), care continuity may suffer.

How it compares vs. 323 WI nursing homes

Overall Medicare rating
1of 5 stars
Better than 0% of WI homes
Staffing rating
1of 5 stars
Better than 0% of WI homes
Health-inspection rating
1of 5 stars
Better than 0% of WI homes
RN turnover
75%
Better than 5% of WI homes

Percentiles rank this facility against every other Medicare-rated nursing home in Wisconsin, using the latest federal data.

Free monitoring

Get an alert if this facility's record changes

We'll email you if its Medicare rating drops, or a new citation, fine, or complaint is filed. Free, unsubscribe anytime.

Safety & Enforcement Federal inspection record

Safety indicators

Abuse indicator None on record
Substantiated complaints 0

Financial penalties

2
Fines
$142,634
Total fines
0
Payment denials
2
Total penalties

Staffing Hours per resident / day

n/a
RN hours per resident / day
Benchmark ≥ 0.75
n/a
Total nursing hours / day
Benchmark ≈ 4.1
n/a
Weekend nursing hours / day
Look for parity with weekdays

Higher staffing, especially RN time, correlates with better outcomes and higher Medicare star ratings.

Recent Deficiency Citations Last 36 months · federal inspections

Loading citation record…

Quality Measures Medicare quality data · lower is better

Loading quality measures…

Highly-rated facilities nearby Same area · by rating